The Bakery's Daily Gamble
Here's the struggle with running a bakery: every time we bake something, we have no idea if anyone will buy it. And if they don't — and you're a scratch bakery that doesn't use preservatives — how long will it stay fresh to sell? Doughnuts last one day, which is why you see day-old-doughnut prices. Cookies and cakes buy you a few more days. But hot hand pies fresh out of our little treehouse oven? A very limited three hours.
The Hot Case Balancing Act
We try to keep a handful of hand pies warm and ready in the nest for guests who wander in and want one on the spot. It's insane. The fight against food waste — and what it costs us — is an ongoing, every day, every minute battle.
We See You Waiting
We try hard to let people know they can pre-order online. Some people take us up on it. Most do not — and that's okay, since most of our customers are still new to us. But every day I work the front window, I see people pull into a parking spot, check their phone, and wait. Why are they waiting? For their Little Caesars app to tell them their pizza is ready. Then they hop out of the car and go pick it up from the warmer locker inside the store.
Why We Want You to Order Ahead
We know ordering online isn't hard — we see people do it every day! We're on a mission to grow a following of customers who order online for pickup. Here's why it's worth the thirty seconds:
- You won't be disappointed when your favorite isn't in the case (we can't read minds — people walk out all the time because we didn't know they were climbing up for a specific hand pie!)
- Your order will be packaged and ready for you to take away, so you can enjoy it wherever you please (we won't tell if it's in the car)
- For us, it cuts down on waste — which means we can keep doing what we love, sustainably
Our Ask
We will never go to an online-only model — we love seeing you climb up to our window. But we'd like to change the narrative a little bit. Order online, or call in your order. When you're dreaming of a pie, make sure you get it.


